“First class work executed on time. Alex turned up on time and planned and executed the work as stated with professionalism and care. I would have no hesitation in recommending him to anyone who needs quality joinery work”
Public evidence profile · Checked May 2026
Shiell Joinery
Trust Score
28out of 100
28 out of 100, with a caution: only 2 reviews held yet. A small public record keeps the evidence thin, and the score reflects that.
- Rated 5.0 from 2 reviews
- Reviewed 10 months ago
How this score is worked out
Rating5.0 / 5
Review volumeLow · 2
Independent sources2 independent public sources
CredentialsNo credentials shown yet
How this score is made up
What customers say18.4 of 60
Independent checks7 of 30
Track record2.5 of 10
See the independent checks
- Licences and credentials0 of 8.3
- Ways to reach them7 of 8.3
- Reviewed on more than one site0 of 6.2
- Registered company details0 of 4.1
- Photos of their work0 of 2.1
- Industry recognition0 of 1
Missing evidence lowers the score because we can't check it. It doesn't mean it doesn't exist. Claiming a profile never changes the score. Evidence context, not a guarantee of workmanship.
Reviews · public evidence
What customers say
These reviews are published independently on the named public source below, not testimonials this business chose to show. We bring them together and link each one back to where it appeared, so you can open the source and read it yourself.
5.0out of 5
Where these reviews are published
- Checkatrade2 reviews · 5.0 avg
Highlights
“I hired Shiell Joinery to take over a flooring job in my new kitchen extension after being let down by a previous joiner. They did a fantastic job, easily the best joiners I’ve ever worked with. The team arrived on time, were polite, respected my property, and kept me updated throughout the process. Communication was excellent, the workmanship was top quality, and the price was very fair. It’s a real relief to find a reliable, professional company in a market full of hit-and-miss tradesmen. I would definitely recommend Shiell Joinery to anyone looking for a trustworthy and skilled team.”
Detailed reviews
First class work executed on time. Alex turned up on time and planned and executed the work as stated with professionalism and care. I would have no hesitation in recommending him to anyone who needs quality joinery work
I hired Shiell Joinery to take over a flooring job in my new kitchen extension after being let down by a previous joiner. They did a fantastic job, easily the best joiners I’ve ever worked with. The team arrived on time, were polite, respected my property, and kept me updated throughout the process. Communication was excellent, the workmanship was top quality, and the price was very fair. It’s a real relief to find a reliable, professional company in a market full of hit-and-miss tradesmen. I would definitely recommend Shiell Joinery to anyone looking for a trustworthy and skilled team.
Local context
Rated 5.0, above the local average for tilers in Edinburgh
Across 28 tilers in Edinburgh, the typical rating is 4.8 out of 5. We compare against the same businesses a homeowner would find searching for this trade locally.
Sources
2 named public sourcesWhere this information comes from
Everything on this page is drawn from named public sources. Where a source provides a public link, you can open the original and dig deeper.
Review sources
Business and public registers
Public evidence last checked May 2026
About
Carpets / flooring in Edinburgh, Edinburgh.
Your own checks
What to check before you hire
Worth checking yourself
Only a few public reviews are shown. Ask for recent references you can contact.
No credentials are shown here and the business has not claimed this profile. Ask to see certificates and insurance directly.
Look for consistent reviews across several named sources, not one polished profile.
Check any credential evidence, and that the business details independently check out.
Get a written quote and keep guarantee, insurance and payment terms in writing.
Want an extra legitimacy check? Run the Cowboy Checker on Shiell Joinery before you contact them.
Run Cowboy Checker →Good to know
Common questions about Shiell Joinery
Is Shiell Joinery a legitimate business?
Shiell Joinery has 2 independent public reviews, rated 5 out of 5. This is independent public evidence gathered from named public sources (no ads, no paid placement), not a guarantee of workmanship. If anything here is out of date, the business can request a correction.
What do customers say about Shiell Joinery?
Shiell Joinery has 2 public reviews, averaging 5 out of 5. You can read the individual reviews and where each came from in the reviews section above.
How do I know Shiell Joinery's reviews are genuine?
Shiell Joinery's 2 public reviews come from a named public review source, and MyTrustedTraders links every one back to where it was published, so you can open the source and read them yourself rather than trusting a single curated page. MyTrustedTraders brings this public evidence together with no ads and no paid placement: we show where every review came from rather than selling rankings, so you can weigh the evidence for yourself.
Edina Tiles
SP Tiling
43Trust ScoreBuilding a public recordout of 100
22 reviews · Reviewed 9 months ago
Harper Tiling & Bathrooms
40Trust ScoreBuilding a public recordout of 100
31 reviews (3 in the last 12 months)
HI Tile
34Trust ScoreBuilding a public recordout of 100
13 reviews
Peter Wood Tiling
Known for: Punctual